Whether we’re living it ourselves or have someone close to us who’s looking for companionship, many of us are only within one degree of separation from understanding the realities of today’s challenging singles scene. The public has spoken—largely women—and online dating just isn’t measuring up. That sentiment is pretty mild compared to the horror stories that get retold in our circles, not unlike spooky tales whispered around a campfire.
It’s easy to focus on the negative aspects of dating apps and dating in general, but there aren’t very many solutions in that approach. Finding an expert to weigh in on this subject was admittedly daunting, but a bit of sleuthing resulted in a connection with Dr. Mikhila Wildey, Clinical Psychologist and Associate Professor of Psychology at Grand Valley State University.
Dr. Wildey is a couples therapist at her practice: Resilient Relationships. But, what’s more helpful in this context is the research she’s conducted on dating and early romantic relationship development through her role at GVSU. Bingo! Following is our full conversation.
WMW: I’ve heard a lot of suggestions like joining Meetup groups and doing speed dating, but these seem to have their drawbacks (often involving the same pool of people). Could these be legitimate options for app-free dating? If so, what should people consider?
Dr. Wildey: Meetup groups absolutely can work, but how you choose them matters. You want to pick something you’d enjoy even if you never meet anyone there. If you join a group just to find a partner, you’ll probably quit when it doesn’t happen quickly. If you love it, you’ll keep showing up and you’ll be more of yourself. Picking a group that meets regularly and continuing to show up matters, because attraction often grows the more time we spend around someone. I should also add that even if no one in the group is a match, everyone there knows other people. As you get to know them, you’re also getting closer to their friends, coworkers, and siblings. Your future partner might not be in the room, but someone in the room might know them.
Speed-dating is more about first impressions, and three to five minutes is a small window. Outside of bigger cities, the events also tend to be smaller, so you may end up seeing the same faces. If there’s a spark, great, but you’ll want to give that person a few more chances to see if there is a more real connection.
WMW: Matchmaking services are often costly and do not guarantee a match. What are your thoughts on going this route?
Dr. Wildey: Many services promise that matching people based on similar personalities will lead to a better relationship. My research has found that this is mostly an illusion. Personality similarity has very little to do with how happy couples are in the long run. If you go this route, I’d recommend thinking of it as paying for access. You should ask who they work with, how many people they have locally, and how they screen for serious clients. A good matchmaker should get you in the room with people you wouldn’t otherwise meet. Whether you then have compatibility with that person regarding shared values and future goals is something only time with that person will tell you.
WMW: Someone brought up the Burned Haystack Method, but this seems to apply more to online dating. Could this approach be used in an analog situation?
Dr. Wildey: Part of this method is useful offline: you should know your dealbreakers and be clear about them. It’s important, though, to understand that a true dealbreaker is a difference with no middle ground. For example, one person wants kids and the other doesn’t. One person wants an exclusive long-term relationship and the other doesn’t. Or faith is central to one person’s daily life, including how they’d raise their children, and the other person doesn’t share it. Those are all areas where finding compromise would be very difficult. Almost everything outside of true dealbreakers is more flexible than people think. We’re surprisingly bad at predicting who we’ll be drawn to before we meet them, and a lot of the hard lines soften once you actually get to know someone. Every relationship that lasts requires some flexibility.
WMW: On a more positive note, what are some practical tips you have for navigating dating without apps? Or just navigating dating in general?
Dr. Wildey: I always encourage people to get clear on themselves first. Know what you need, what your real dealbreakers are, and what you’re willing to be flexible on. And keep in mind that flexibility is necessary for any relationship to work.
Related to what I mentioned in the meetup groups question, build a life you enjoy first, and build it around other people. Even if you’re introverted and group activities aren’t your style, start with what you already like doing alone. Most hobbies do have a group version, like a pottery studio, a running club, or a book club.
It’s helpful to tell the people around you that you are looking for a partner. Friends may know someone who might be a good fit but won’t say anything unless they know you’re open to it.
Because so much dating now happens on apps, asking someone to coffee in person feels much scarier than swiping. Many people are out of practice at making the first move. I’d recommend practicing, because it does get easier the more you do it. You may also be surprised at how good it feels to put yourself out there, even if it doesn’t turn into something longer.
WMW: What have I not asked you about this topic that I should have?
Dr. Wildey: I think a central challenge to dating without apps right now is that we’re more isolated than we used to be. People used to meet more naturally through neighborhoods, community events, congregations, and the like. If meeting someone feels harder, it’s not because you’re doing it wrong. It actually is harder. You have to be more intentional about finding these opportunities, and that takes time and effort. But even if you don’t meet a partner by putting yourself out there, you’re still building meaningful connections with other people. Social connection is one of our most basic human needs.
I would also emphasize that attraction isn’t always instant, and giving people a second chance is helpful. Some of the best relationships start out as a slow build or a friendship. Don’t rule someone out after one mediocre conversation over coffee.
Allison Kay Bannister has been a West Michigan resident since 1987 and a professional writer since 2002. A GVSU alumna, she launched her own freelance writing business in 2017. Allison is a cookie connoisseur, word nerd, aspiring gardener, and metastatic breast cancer thriver who loves traveling in Michigan and beyond, and enjoys art, world cuisine, wine, music, and making homemade preserves.
The abridged, original version of this article originally appeared in the Winter ‘26/’27 issue of West Michigan Woman.

